Bike model comparison
Ribble R872 vs Planet X Pro Carbon
An honest, data-led look at how the Ribble R872 and Planet X Pro Carbon compare on price, ride, resale and what UK riders actually buy.
Overview
The classic British direct-sell argument, and the single most-argued comparison on the road.cc forum. Both are carbon road frames from UK companies that sell online and skip the shop margin. Ribble builds in Lancashire and finishes to a tidier standard; Planet X built its name in Rotherham on aggressive pricing and end-of-line deals. You are choosing between a cleaner package and a cheaper one.
At a glance
Quick verdict
speed
Tie
comfort
Ribble R872
versatility
Ribble R872
value
Planet X Pro Carbon
Planet X is the cheapest way into a carbon road bike; Ribble is the better-finished one that is easier to sell on. Outlay against ownership.
- Pick the Planet X Pro Carbon if the priority is getting onto carbon for the least money.
- Pick the Ribble R872 if you want to spec the build and keep the bike for years.
- Ribble holds value more reliably used, so the gap at resale is smaller than the gap at purchase.
- Neither has a local dealer, so factor in posting the bike back if a warranty issue comes up.
Feature by feature
Feature comparison
| Feature | Ribble R872 | Planet X Pro Carbon |
|---|---|---|
Buying Ribble lets you spec it, Planet X sells what it has | Direct online, custom build picker | Direct online, deal-led stock |
Value Planet X wins on pure outlay | Keen for a finished bike | Cheaper, often much cheaper |
Finish Ribble looks the more expensive bike | Tidier paint and detailing | Functional, plainer |
Resale Ribble is the easier resale | Holds value better used | Cheap to buy, cheap to sell |
Decide
Which is best for you?
Choose Ribble R872 if...
- Riders who want to spec a build
- A finished bike straight out of the box
- Better resale later
- UK support and servicing parts
Choose Planet X Pro Carbon if...
- The lowest cost of entry to carbon
- Riders happy to upgrade parts over time
- Bargain hunters watching stock clearances
- A first carbon bike on a tight budget
Community
Have your say
Riding Ribble R872 or Planet X Pro Carbon, or stuck choosing? Ask the Cyclesite community before you buy.
c/bike-comparisons
Bike Comparisons
No threads yet
Be the first to weigh in on Ribble R872 vs Planet X Pro Carbon. Ask the community before you buy, or share what you ride and why.
Start the conversationQuestions
Frequently asked questions
Is the Ribble R872 or Planet X Pro Carbon better?
The R872 is the better finished bike and holds its value more reliably. The Pro Carbon is the cheaper way into a carbon frame and has long been the bargain pick. If you plan to keep it for years and sell it on, the Ribble is easier to live with. If you want carbon for the least money, the Planet X makes more sense.
Are they good value used?
Both are strong used buys because the original owner absorbed the direct-sell discount. Planet X frames in particular sit at low used prices, which is good news buying and less good news selling. Check our live price panel for what each is currently being advertised at.
Do you get a warranty buying direct?
Yes, both sell with a manufacturer warranty, but there is no local dealer to take the bike back to. You deal with the company directly and post the bike if it comes to that. Factor that in if you would rather hand a problem to a shop.
Keep comparing
Other comparisons
Road Bikes vs Gravel Bikes
Road Bikes vs Hybrid Bikes
Mountain Bikes vs Gravel Bikes
Electric Bikes vs Road Bikes
Endurance Road Bikes vs Race Bikes
Trek Domane vs Specialized Roubaix
Specialized Tarmac vs Trek Emonda
Specialized Diverge vs Cannondale Topstone
Trek Madone vs Canyon Aeroad
Giant TCR vs Canyon Ultimate
Giant Defy vs Trek Domane
Trek Checkpoint vs Canyon Grizl
Specialized Stumpjumper vs Trek Fuel EX
Cannondale Synapse vs Specialized Roubaix
Trek Marlin vs Giant Talon
Specialized Allez vs Giant Contend
Specialized Turbo Levo vs Trek Rail
Brompton vs Tern
Specialized Rockhopper vs Trek Marlin
Giant Trance vs Specialized Stumpjumper
Trek Fuel EX vs Santa Cruz Hightower
Giant Revolt vs Specialized Diverge
Cannondale Topstone vs Canyon Grizl
Specialized Tarmac vs Canyon Ultimate
Specialized Epic vs Trek Supercaliber
Giant Reign vs Specialized Enduro
Specialized Sirrus vs Giant Escape
Specialized Turbo Vado vs Trek Allant
Canyon Aeroad vs Giant Propel
Specialized Tarmac vs Trek Madone
Trek Emonda vs Canyon Ultimate
Specialized Roubaix vs Canyon Endurace
Giant Defy vs Cube Agree
Canyon Ultimate vs Canyon Endurace
Genesis Croix de Fer vs Ribble CGR
Boardman SLR vs Ribble R872
Cannondale vs Canyon
Cube vs Trek
Cube vs Specialized
Trek vs Specialized
Canyon vs Specialized
Giant vs Trek
Specialized vs Giant
Canyon vs Trek
Giant vs Canyon
Cannondale vs Specialized
Cannondale vs Trek
Ribble vs Canyon
Cube vs Giant
Santa Cruz vs Trek