Bike type comparison
Specialized TarmacvsTrek Madone
A side-by-side UK buyer's guide to help you pick the right type of bike for how you actually ride.
Overview
Two flagship race bikes with different priorities. The Tarmac is Specialized's all-rounder, balancing low weight with aero shaping. The Madone is Trek's dedicated aero bike, with deep tubes and an IsoFlow cutout for a little compliance. On flat, fast roads the Madone has the aero edge; everywhere else the Tarmac's versatility shows.
At a glance
Quick verdict
speed
Tie
comfort
Tie
versatility
Specialized Tarmac
value
Tie
The all-rounder against the aero specialist. The Tarmac is lighter and more versatile; the Madone is faster on flat, fast roads.
- Pick the Tarmac for one race bike that does everything.
- Pick the Madone for outright aero speed on fast roads.
- Tarmac climbs better; Madone wins the flat.
- Used, inspect carbon at the head tube and bottom bracket.
Feature by feature
Feature comparison
| Feature | Specialized Tarmac | Trek Madone |
|---|---|---|
Focus Tarmac does more jobs | Light plus aero all-rounder | Dedicated aero |
Aero Madone edges flat-out speed | Aero shaping | Deeper, more aero |
Climbing Tarmac is better uphill | Lighter, livelier | Heavier aero frame |
Compliance Madone has a touch more | Race-firm | IsoFlow adds a little give |
Decide
Which is best for you?
Choose Specialized Tarmac if...
- One race bike for everything
- Hilly and mixed routes
- Aero plus low weight
- Racing and fast group rides
Choose Trek Madone if...
- Flat, fast roads and aero gains
- Riders who prioritise top speed
- Crit and fast bunch efforts
- A dedicated aero weapon
Community
Have your say
Riding Specialized Tarmac or Trek Madone, or stuck choosing? Ask the Cyclesite community before you buy.
c/bike-comparisons
Bike Comparisons
No threads yet
Be the first to weigh in on Specialized Tarmac vs Trek Madone. Ask the community before you buy, or share what you ride and why.
Start the conversationQuestions
Frequently asked questions
Is the Tarmac or Madone better?
It depends on your roads. The Madone is the more aero bike, faster on flat, fast roads; the Tarmac is the lighter all-rounder that climbs better and does everything. For most mixed UK riding the Tarmac is the more versatile choice.
Is the Madone comfortable?
It has an IsoFlow cutout that adds a little compliance, but it is still a firm race bike, not an endurance bike. For real all-day comfort, look at a Domane or Roubaix.
Which should I buy used?
Both are flagship platforms that hold value. Inspect the carbon carefully at the head tube and bottom bracket, check for crash damage, and buy on which suits your roads and comes at the right price.
Keep comparing
Other comparisons
Road Bikes vs Gravel Bikes
Road Bikes vs Hybrid Bikes
Mountain Bikes vs Gravel Bikes
Electric Bikes vs Road Bikes
Endurance Road Bikes vs Race Bikes
Trek Domane vs Specialized Roubaix
Specialized Tarmac vs Trek Emonda
Specialized Diverge vs Cannondale Topstone
Trek Madone vs Canyon Aeroad
Giant TCR vs Canyon Ultimate
Giant Defy vs Trek Domane
Trek Checkpoint vs Canyon Grizl
Specialized Stumpjumper vs Trek Fuel EX
Cannondale Synapse vs Specialized Roubaix
Trek Marlin vs Giant Talon
Specialized Allez vs Giant Contend
Specialized Turbo Levo vs Trek Rail
Brompton vs Tern
Specialized Rockhopper vs Trek Marlin
Giant Trance vs Specialized Stumpjumper
Trek Fuel EX vs Santa Cruz Hightower
Giant Revolt vs Specialized Diverge
Cannondale Topstone vs Canyon Grizl
Specialized Tarmac vs Canyon Ultimate
Specialized Epic vs Trek Supercaliber
Giant Reign vs Specialized Enduro
Specialized Sirrus vs Giant Escape
Specialized Turbo Vado vs Trek Allant
Canyon Aeroad vs Giant Propel
Trek Emonda vs Canyon Ultimate
Specialized Roubaix vs Canyon Endurace
Trek vs Specialized
Canyon vs Specialized
Giant vs Trek
Specialized vs Giant
Canyon vs Trek
Giant vs Canyon
Cannondale vs Specialized
Cannondale vs Trek
Ribble vs Canyon
Cube vs Giant
Santa Cruz vs Trek